Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts: Lessons from photosynthesis

G Charles Dismukes, Robin Brimblecombe, Greg A N Felton, Ruslan S. Pryadun, John E. Sheats, Leone Spiccia, Gerhard F. Swiegers

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

360 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Hydrogen is the most promising fuel of the future owing to its carbon-free, high-energy content and potential to be efficiently converted into either electrical or thermal energy. The greatest technical barrier to accessing this renewable resource remains the inability to create inexpensive catalysts for the solar-driven oxidation of water. To date, the most efficient system that uses solar energy to oxidize water is the photosystem II water-oxidizing complex (PSII-WOC), which is found within naturally occurring photosynthetic organisms. The catalytic core of this enzyme is a CaMn4Ox cluster, which is present in all known species of oxygenic phototrophs and has been conserved since the emergence of this type of photosynthesis about 2.5 billion years ago. The key features that facilitate the catalytic success of the PSII-WOC offer important lessons for the design of abiological water oxidation catalysts. In this Account, we examine the chemical principles that may govern the PSII-WOC by comparing the water oxidation capabilities of structurally related synthetic manganese-oxo complexes, particularly those with a cubical Mn4O4 core ("cubanes"). We summarize this research, from the self-assembly of the first such clusters, through the elucidation of their mechanism of photoinduced rearrangement to release O 2, to recent advances highlighting their capability to catalyze sustained light-activated electrolysis of water. The [Mn4O 4]6+ cubane core assembles spontaneously in solution from monomeric precursors or from [Mn2O2]3+ core complexes in the presence of metrically appropriate bidentate chelates, for example, diarylphosphinates (ligands of Ph2PO2 - and 4-phenyl- substituted derivatives), which bridge pairs of Mn atoms on each cube face (Mn4O4L6). The [Mn4O 4]6+ core is enlarged relative to the [Mn 2O2]3+ core, resulting in considerably weaker Mn-O bonds. Cubanes are ferocious oxidizing agents, stronger than analogous complexes with the [Mn2O2]3+ core, as demonstrated both by the range of substrates they dehydrogenate or oxygenate (unactivated alkanes, for example) and the 25% larger O-H bond enthalpy of the resulting μ3-OH bridge. The cubane core topology is structurally suited to releasing O2, and it does so in high yield upon removal of one phosphinate by photoexcitation in the gas phase or thermal excitation in the solid state. This is quite unlike other Mn-oxo complexes and can be attributed to the elongated Mn-O bond lengths and low-energy transition state to the μ-peroxo precursor. The photoproduct, [Mn4O2L 5]+, an intact nonplanar butterfly core complex, is poised for oxidative regeneration of the cubane core upon binding of two water molecules and coupling to an anode. Catalytic evolution of O2 and protons from water exceeding 1000 turnovers can be readily achieved by suspending the oxidized cubane, [Mn4O4L6] +, into a proton-conducting membrane (Nafion) preadsorbed onto a conducting electrode and electroxidizing the photoreduced butterfly complexes by the application of an external bias. Catalytic water oxidation can be achieved using sunlight as the only source of energy by replacing the external electrical bias with redox coupling to a photoanode incorporating a Ru(bipyridyl) dye.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1935-1943
Number of pages9
JournalAccounts of Chemical Research
Volume42
Issue number12
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 21 2009

Fingerprint

Photosynthesis
Oxidation
Catalysts
Water
Photosystem II Protein Complex
Protons
2,2'-Dipyridyl
Alkanes
Photoexcitation
Bond length
Manganese
Thermal energy
Electrolysis
Oxidants
Self assembly
Solar energy
Hydrogen
Enthalpy
Anodes
Coloring Agents

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemistry(all)

Cite this

Dismukes, G. C., Brimblecombe, R., Felton, G. A. N., Pryadun, R. S., Sheats, J. E., Spiccia, L., & Swiegers, G. F. (2009). Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts: Lessons from photosynthesis. Accounts of Chemical Research, 42(12), 1935-1943. https://doi.org/10.1021/ar900249x

Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts : Lessons from photosynthesis. / Dismukes, G Charles; Brimblecombe, Robin; Felton, Greg A N; Pryadun, Ruslan S.; Sheats, John E.; Spiccia, Leone; Swiegers, Gerhard F.

In: Accounts of Chemical Research, Vol. 42, No. 12, 21.12.2009, p. 1935-1943.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dismukes, GC, Brimblecombe, R, Felton, GAN, Pryadun, RS, Sheats, JE, Spiccia, L & Swiegers, GF 2009, 'Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts: Lessons from photosynthesis', Accounts of Chemical Research, vol. 42, no. 12, pp. 1935-1943. https://doi.org/10.1021/ar900249x
Dismukes, G Charles ; Brimblecombe, Robin ; Felton, Greg A N ; Pryadun, Ruslan S. ; Sheats, John E. ; Spiccia, Leone ; Swiegers, Gerhard F. / Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts : Lessons from photosynthesis. In: Accounts of Chemical Research. 2009 ; Vol. 42, No. 12. pp. 1935-1943.
@article{91cf9427b26b409c905619558aa2715d,
title = "Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts: Lessons from photosynthesis",
abstract = "Hydrogen is the most promising fuel of the future owing to its carbon-free, high-energy content and potential to be efficiently converted into either electrical or thermal energy. The greatest technical barrier to accessing this renewable resource remains the inability to create inexpensive catalysts for the solar-driven oxidation of water. To date, the most efficient system that uses solar energy to oxidize water is the photosystem II water-oxidizing complex (PSII-WOC), which is found within naturally occurring photosynthetic organisms. The catalytic core of this enzyme is a CaMn4Ox cluster, which is present in all known species of oxygenic phototrophs and has been conserved since the emergence of this type of photosynthesis about 2.5 billion years ago. The key features that facilitate the catalytic success of the PSII-WOC offer important lessons for the design of abiological water oxidation catalysts. In this Account, we examine the chemical principles that may govern the PSII-WOC by comparing the water oxidation capabilities of structurally related synthetic manganese-oxo complexes, particularly those with a cubical Mn4O4 core ({"}cubanes{"}). We summarize this research, from the self-assembly of the first such clusters, through the elucidation of their mechanism of photoinduced rearrangement to release O 2, to recent advances highlighting their capability to catalyze sustained light-activated electrolysis of water. The [Mn4O 4]6+ cubane core assembles spontaneously in solution from monomeric precursors or from [Mn2O2]3+ core complexes in the presence of metrically appropriate bidentate chelates, for example, diarylphosphinates (ligands of Ph2PO2 - and 4-phenyl- substituted derivatives), which bridge pairs of Mn atoms on each cube face (Mn4O4L6). The [Mn4O 4]6+ core is enlarged relative to the [Mn 2O2]3+ core, resulting in considerably weaker Mn-O bonds. Cubanes are ferocious oxidizing agents, stronger than analogous complexes with the [Mn2O2]3+ core, as demonstrated both by the range of substrates they dehydrogenate or oxygenate (unactivated alkanes, for example) and the 25{\%} larger O-H bond enthalpy of the resulting μ3-OH bridge. The cubane core topology is structurally suited to releasing O2, and it does so in high yield upon removal of one phosphinate by photoexcitation in the gas phase or thermal excitation in the solid state. This is quite unlike other Mn-oxo complexes and can be attributed to the elongated Mn-O bond lengths and low-energy transition state to the μ-peroxo precursor. The photoproduct, [Mn4O2L 5]+, an intact nonplanar butterfly core complex, is poised for oxidative regeneration of the cubane core upon binding of two water molecules and coupling to an anode. Catalytic evolution of O2 and protons from water exceeding 1000 turnovers can be readily achieved by suspending the oxidized cubane, [Mn4O4L6] +, into a proton-conducting membrane (Nafion) preadsorbed onto a conducting electrode and electroxidizing the photoreduced butterfly complexes by the application of an external bias. Catalytic water oxidation can be achieved using sunlight as the only source of energy by replacing the external electrical bias with redox coupling to a photoanode incorporating a Ru(bipyridyl) dye.",
author = "Dismukes, {G Charles} and Robin Brimblecombe and Felton, {Greg A N} and Pryadun, {Ruslan S.} and Sheats, {John E.} and Leone Spiccia and Swiegers, {Gerhard F.}",
year = "2009",
month = "12",
day = "21",
doi = "10.1021/ar900249x",
language = "English",
volume = "42",
pages = "1935--1943",
journal = "Accounts of Chemical Research",
issn = "0001-4842",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Development of bioinspired Mn4O4-cubane water oxidation catalysts

T2 - Lessons from photosynthesis

AU - Dismukes, G Charles

AU - Brimblecombe, Robin

AU - Felton, Greg A N

AU - Pryadun, Ruslan S.

AU - Sheats, John E.

AU - Spiccia, Leone

AU - Swiegers, Gerhard F.

PY - 2009/12/21

Y1 - 2009/12/21

N2 - Hydrogen is the most promising fuel of the future owing to its carbon-free, high-energy content and potential to be efficiently converted into either electrical or thermal energy. The greatest technical barrier to accessing this renewable resource remains the inability to create inexpensive catalysts for the solar-driven oxidation of water. To date, the most efficient system that uses solar energy to oxidize water is the photosystem II water-oxidizing complex (PSII-WOC), which is found within naturally occurring photosynthetic organisms. The catalytic core of this enzyme is a CaMn4Ox cluster, which is present in all known species of oxygenic phototrophs and has been conserved since the emergence of this type of photosynthesis about 2.5 billion years ago. The key features that facilitate the catalytic success of the PSII-WOC offer important lessons for the design of abiological water oxidation catalysts. In this Account, we examine the chemical principles that may govern the PSII-WOC by comparing the water oxidation capabilities of structurally related synthetic manganese-oxo complexes, particularly those with a cubical Mn4O4 core ("cubanes"). We summarize this research, from the self-assembly of the first such clusters, through the elucidation of their mechanism of photoinduced rearrangement to release O 2, to recent advances highlighting their capability to catalyze sustained light-activated electrolysis of water. The [Mn4O 4]6+ cubane core assembles spontaneously in solution from monomeric precursors or from [Mn2O2]3+ core complexes in the presence of metrically appropriate bidentate chelates, for example, diarylphosphinates (ligands of Ph2PO2 - and 4-phenyl- substituted derivatives), which bridge pairs of Mn atoms on each cube face (Mn4O4L6). The [Mn4O 4]6+ core is enlarged relative to the [Mn 2O2]3+ core, resulting in considerably weaker Mn-O bonds. Cubanes are ferocious oxidizing agents, stronger than analogous complexes with the [Mn2O2]3+ core, as demonstrated both by the range of substrates they dehydrogenate or oxygenate (unactivated alkanes, for example) and the 25% larger O-H bond enthalpy of the resulting μ3-OH bridge. The cubane core topology is structurally suited to releasing O2, and it does so in high yield upon removal of one phosphinate by photoexcitation in the gas phase or thermal excitation in the solid state. This is quite unlike other Mn-oxo complexes and can be attributed to the elongated Mn-O bond lengths and low-energy transition state to the μ-peroxo precursor. The photoproduct, [Mn4O2L 5]+, an intact nonplanar butterfly core complex, is poised for oxidative regeneration of the cubane core upon binding of two water molecules and coupling to an anode. Catalytic evolution of O2 and protons from water exceeding 1000 turnovers can be readily achieved by suspending the oxidized cubane, [Mn4O4L6] +, into a proton-conducting membrane (Nafion) preadsorbed onto a conducting electrode and electroxidizing the photoreduced butterfly complexes by the application of an external bias. Catalytic water oxidation can be achieved using sunlight as the only source of energy by replacing the external electrical bias with redox coupling to a photoanode incorporating a Ru(bipyridyl) dye.

AB - Hydrogen is the most promising fuel of the future owing to its carbon-free, high-energy content and potential to be efficiently converted into either electrical or thermal energy. The greatest technical barrier to accessing this renewable resource remains the inability to create inexpensive catalysts for the solar-driven oxidation of water. To date, the most efficient system that uses solar energy to oxidize water is the photosystem II water-oxidizing complex (PSII-WOC), which is found within naturally occurring photosynthetic organisms. The catalytic core of this enzyme is a CaMn4Ox cluster, which is present in all known species of oxygenic phototrophs and has been conserved since the emergence of this type of photosynthesis about 2.5 billion years ago. The key features that facilitate the catalytic success of the PSII-WOC offer important lessons for the design of abiological water oxidation catalysts. In this Account, we examine the chemical principles that may govern the PSII-WOC by comparing the water oxidation capabilities of structurally related synthetic manganese-oxo complexes, particularly those with a cubical Mn4O4 core ("cubanes"). We summarize this research, from the self-assembly of the first such clusters, through the elucidation of their mechanism of photoinduced rearrangement to release O 2, to recent advances highlighting their capability to catalyze sustained light-activated electrolysis of water. The [Mn4O 4]6+ cubane core assembles spontaneously in solution from monomeric precursors or from [Mn2O2]3+ core complexes in the presence of metrically appropriate bidentate chelates, for example, diarylphosphinates (ligands of Ph2PO2 - and 4-phenyl- substituted derivatives), which bridge pairs of Mn atoms on each cube face (Mn4O4L6). The [Mn4O 4]6+ core is enlarged relative to the [Mn 2O2]3+ core, resulting in considerably weaker Mn-O bonds. Cubanes are ferocious oxidizing agents, stronger than analogous complexes with the [Mn2O2]3+ core, as demonstrated both by the range of substrates they dehydrogenate or oxygenate (unactivated alkanes, for example) and the 25% larger O-H bond enthalpy of the resulting μ3-OH bridge. The cubane core topology is structurally suited to releasing O2, and it does so in high yield upon removal of one phosphinate by photoexcitation in the gas phase or thermal excitation in the solid state. This is quite unlike other Mn-oxo complexes and can be attributed to the elongated Mn-O bond lengths and low-energy transition state to the μ-peroxo precursor. The photoproduct, [Mn4O2L 5]+, an intact nonplanar butterfly core complex, is poised for oxidative regeneration of the cubane core upon binding of two water molecules and coupling to an anode. Catalytic evolution of O2 and protons from water exceeding 1000 turnovers can be readily achieved by suspending the oxidized cubane, [Mn4O4L6] +, into a proton-conducting membrane (Nafion) preadsorbed onto a conducting electrode and electroxidizing the photoreduced butterfly complexes by the application of an external bias. Catalytic water oxidation can be achieved using sunlight as the only source of energy by replacing the external electrical bias with redox coupling to a photoanode incorporating a Ru(bipyridyl) dye.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=72949084147&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=72949084147&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/ar900249x

DO - 10.1021/ar900249x

M3 - Article

C2 - 19908827

AN - SCOPUS:72949084147

VL - 42

SP - 1935

EP - 1943

JO - Accounts of Chemical Research

JF - Accounts of Chemical Research

SN - 0001-4842

IS - 12

ER -