Emergence of a few distinct structures from a single formal structure type during high-throughput screening for stable compounds

The case of RbCuS and RbCuSe

Giancarlo Trimarchi, Xiuwen Zhang, Michael J. Devries Vermeer, Jacqueline Cantwell, Kenneth R Poeppelmeier, Alex Zunger

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Theoretical sorting of stable and synthesizable "missing compounds" from those that are unstable is a crucial step in the discovery of previously unknown functional materials. This active research area often involves high-throughput (HT) examination of the total energy of a given compound in a list of candidate formal structure types (FSTs), searching for those with the lowest energy within that list. While it is well appreciated that local relaxation methods based on a fixed list of structure types can lead to inaccurate geometries, this approach is widely used in HT studies because it produces answers faster than global optimization methods (that vary lattice vectors and atomic positions without local restrictions). We find, however, a different failure mode of the HT protocol: specific crystallographic classes of formal structure types each correspond to a series of chemically distinct "daughter structure types" (DSTs) that have the same space group but possess totally different local bonding configurations, including coordination types. Failure to include such DSTs in the fixed list of examined candidate structures used in contemporary high-throughput approaches can lead to qualitative misidentification of the stable bonding pattern, not just quantitative inaccuracies. In this work, we (i) clarify the understanding of the general DST-FST relationship, thus improving current discovery HT approaches, (ii) illustrate this failure mode for RbCuS and RbCuSe (the latter being a yet unreported compound and is predicted here) by developing a synthesis method and accelerated crystal-structure determination, and (iii) apply the genetic-algorithm-based global space-group optimization (GSGO) approach which is not vulnerable to the failure mode of HT searches of fixed lists, demonstrating a correct identification of the stable DST. The broad impact of items (i)-(iii) lies in the demonstrated predictive ability of a more comprehensive search strategy than what is currently used - use HT calculations as the preliminary broad screening followed by unbiased GSGO of the final candidates.

Original languageEnglish
Article number165103
JournalPhysical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics
Volume92
Issue number16
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2 2015

Fingerprint

lists
Screening
screening
Throughput
failure modes
Failure modes
optimization
classifying
genetic algorithms
Functional materials
constrictions
examination
Global optimization
Sorting
crystal structure
energy
Crystal structure
Genetic algorithms
synthesis
geometry

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Condensed Matter Physics
  • Electronic, Optical and Magnetic Materials

Cite this

Emergence of a few distinct structures from a single formal structure type during high-throughput screening for stable compounds : The case of RbCuS and RbCuSe. / Trimarchi, Giancarlo; Zhang, Xiuwen; Devries Vermeer, Michael J.; Cantwell, Jacqueline; Poeppelmeier, Kenneth R; Zunger, Alex.

In: Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, Vol. 92, No. 16, 165103, 02.10.2015.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{58654976daa34a988a4936eec9ad1446,
title = "Emergence of a few distinct structures from a single formal structure type during high-throughput screening for stable compounds: The case of RbCuS and RbCuSe",
abstract = "Theoretical sorting of stable and synthesizable {"}missing compounds{"} from those that are unstable is a crucial step in the discovery of previously unknown functional materials. This active research area often involves high-throughput (HT) examination of the total energy of a given compound in a list of candidate formal structure types (FSTs), searching for those with the lowest energy within that list. While it is well appreciated that local relaxation methods based on a fixed list of structure types can lead to inaccurate geometries, this approach is widely used in HT studies because it produces answers faster than global optimization methods (that vary lattice vectors and atomic positions without local restrictions). We find, however, a different failure mode of the HT protocol: specific crystallographic classes of formal structure types each correspond to a series of chemically distinct {"}daughter structure types{"} (DSTs) that have the same space group but possess totally different local bonding configurations, including coordination types. Failure to include such DSTs in the fixed list of examined candidate structures used in contemporary high-throughput approaches can lead to qualitative misidentification of the stable bonding pattern, not just quantitative inaccuracies. In this work, we (i) clarify the understanding of the general DST-FST relationship, thus improving current discovery HT approaches, (ii) illustrate this failure mode for RbCuS and RbCuSe (the latter being a yet unreported compound and is predicted here) by developing a synthesis method and accelerated crystal-structure determination, and (iii) apply the genetic-algorithm-based global space-group optimization (GSGO) approach which is not vulnerable to the failure mode of HT searches of fixed lists, demonstrating a correct identification of the stable DST. The broad impact of items (i)-(iii) lies in the demonstrated predictive ability of a more comprehensive search strategy than what is currently used - use HT calculations as the preliminary broad screening followed by unbiased GSGO of the final candidates.",
author = "Giancarlo Trimarchi and Xiuwen Zhang and {Devries Vermeer}, {Michael J.} and Jacqueline Cantwell and Poeppelmeier, {Kenneth R} and Alex Zunger",
year = "2015",
month = "10",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1103/PhysRevB.92.165103",
language = "English",
volume = "92",
journal = "Physical Review B-Condensed Matter",
issn = "1098-0121",
publisher = "American Physical Society",
number = "16",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Emergence of a few distinct structures from a single formal structure type during high-throughput screening for stable compounds

T2 - The case of RbCuS and RbCuSe

AU - Trimarchi, Giancarlo

AU - Zhang, Xiuwen

AU - Devries Vermeer, Michael J.

AU - Cantwell, Jacqueline

AU - Poeppelmeier, Kenneth R

AU - Zunger, Alex

PY - 2015/10/2

Y1 - 2015/10/2

N2 - Theoretical sorting of stable and synthesizable "missing compounds" from those that are unstable is a crucial step in the discovery of previously unknown functional materials. This active research area often involves high-throughput (HT) examination of the total energy of a given compound in a list of candidate formal structure types (FSTs), searching for those with the lowest energy within that list. While it is well appreciated that local relaxation methods based on a fixed list of structure types can lead to inaccurate geometries, this approach is widely used in HT studies because it produces answers faster than global optimization methods (that vary lattice vectors and atomic positions without local restrictions). We find, however, a different failure mode of the HT protocol: specific crystallographic classes of formal structure types each correspond to a series of chemically distinct "daughter structure types" (DSTs) that have the same space group but possess totally different local bonding configurations, including coordination types. Failure to include such DSTs in the fixed list of examined candidate structures used in contemporary high-throughput approaches can lead to qualitative misidentification of the stable bonding pattern, not just quantitative inaccuracies. In this work, we (i) clarify the understanding of the general DST-FST relationship, thus improving current discovery HT approaches, (ii) illustrate this failure mode for RbCuS and RbCuSe (the latter being a yet unreported compound and is predicted here) by developing a synthesis method and accelerated crystal-structure determination, and (iii) apply the genetic-algorithm-based global space-group optimization (GSGO) approach which is not vulnerable to the failure mode of HT searches of fixed lists, demonstrating a correct identification of the stable DST. The broad impact of items (i)-(iii) lies in the demonstrated predictive ability of a more comprehensive search strategy than what is currently used - use HT calculations as the preliminary broad screening followed by unbiased GSGO of the final candidates.

AB - Theoretical sorting of stable and synthesizable "missing compounds" from those that are unstable is a crucial step in the discovery of previously unknown functional materials. This active research area often involves high-throughput (HT) examination of the total energy of a given compound in a list of candidate formal structure types (FSTs), searching for those with the lowest energy within that list. While it is well appreciated that local relaxation methods based on a fixed list of structure types can lead to inaccurate geometries, this approach is widely used in HT studies because it produces answers faster than global optimization methods (that vary lattice vectors and atomic positions without local restrictions). We find, however, a different failure mode of the HT protocol: specific crystallographic classes of formal structure types each correspond to a series of chemically distinct "daughter structure types" (DSTs) that have the same space group but possess totally different local bonding configurations, including coordination types. Failure to include such DSTs in the fixed list of examined candidate structures used in contemporary high-throughput approaches can lead to qualitative misidentification of the stable bonding pattern, not just quantitative inaccuracies. In this work, we (i) clarify the understanding of the general DST-FST relationship, thus improving current discovery HT approaches, (ii) illustrate this failure mode for RbCuS and RbCuSe (the latter being a yet unreported compound and is predicted here) by developing a synthesis method and accelerated crystal-structure determination, and (iii) apply the genetic-algorithm-based global space-group optimization (GSGO) approach which is not vulnerable to the failure mode of HT searches of fixed lists, demonstrating a correct identification of the stable DST. The broad impact of items (i)-(iii) lies in the demonstrated predictive ability of a more comprehensive search strategy than what is currently used - use HT calculations as the preliminary broad screening followed by unbiased GSGO of the final candidates.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84944754873&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84944754873&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1103/PhysRevB.92.165103

DO - 10.1103/PhysRevB.92.165103

M3 - Article

VL - 92

JO - Physical Review B-Condensed Matter

JF - Physical Review B-Condensed Matter

SN - 1098-0121

IS - 16

M1 - 165103

ER -