Probabilities for classically forbidden transitions using classical and classical path methods

James Muckerman, Millard Alexander, Isak Rusinek, R. E. Roberts

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

44 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Limits are established for the applicability of purely classical methods for calculating nonreactive, inelastic transition probabilities in collinear collisions of a structureless atom and a harmonic oscillator. These limits, obtained by comparison with previous exact quantum mechanical results, indicate that such methods are inappropriate not only for "classically forbidden" but for many "classically allowed" transitions (in spite of the fact that they are widely used to calculate probabilities for such processes). A classical path method in the context of infinite-order time-dependent perturbation theory is described which yields extremely accurate transition probabilities even for the most classically forbidden transitions in the collinear atom-harmonic oscillator system. The essential features of this method are: (1) the use of the expectation value of the total interaction potential in determining the atom-oscillator (central force) trajectory, and (2) the use of the arithmetic mean of the initial and final velocities of relative motion in the (elastic) central force trajectory. This choice of interaction potential allows the relative motion to be coupled to changes in the internal state of the oscillator. The present classical method is further applied to three-dimensional atom-breathing sphere collisions, and exact quantum mechanical calculations are also carried out. Comparison of the classical path and exact quantum results shows excellent agreement both in the specific inelastic cross section and in the individual partial-wave contributions.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2416-2428
Number of pages13
JournalJournal of Chemical Physics
Volume65
Issue number6
Publication statusPublished - 1976

Fingerprint

forbidden transitions
Atoms
transition probabilities
harmonic oscillators
atoms
Trajectories
oscillators
trajectories
collisions
breathing
perturbation theory
interactions
cross sections

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Atomic and Molecular Physics, and Optics

Cite this

Probabilities for classically forbidden transitions using classical and classical path methods. / Muckerman, James; Alexander, Millard; Rusinek, Isak; Roberts, R. E.

In: Journal of Chemical Physics, Vol. 65, No. 6, 1976, p. 2416-2428.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Muckerman, James ; Alexander, Millard ; Rusinek, Isak ; Roberts, R. E. / Probabilities for classically forbidden transitions using classical and classical path methods. In: Journal of Chemical Physics. 1976 ; Vol. 65, No. 6. pp. 2416-2428.
@article{f264f5e712774e09af880bf3076c47fd,
title = "Probabilities for classically forbidden transitions using classical and classical path methods",
abstract = "Limits are established for the applicability of purely classical methods for calculating nonreactive, inelastic transition probabilities in collinear collisions of a structureless atom and a harmonic oscillator. These limits, obtained by comparison with previous exact quantum mechanical results, indicate that such methods are inappropriate not only for {"}classically forbidden{"} but for many {"}classically allowed{"} transitions (in spite of the fact that they are widely used to calculate probabilities for such processes). A classical path method in the context of infinite-order time-dependent perturbation theory is described which yields extremely accurate transition probabilities even for the most classically forbidden transitions in the collinear atom-harmonic oscillator system. The essential features of this method are: (1) the use of the expectation value of the total interaction potential in determining the atom-oscillator (central force) trajectory, and (2) the use of the arithmetic mean of the initial and final velocities of relative motion in the (elastic) central force trajectory. This choice of interaction potential allows the relative motion to be coupled to changes in the internal state of the oscillator. The present classical method is further applied to three-dimensional atom-breathing sphere collisions, and exact quantum mechanical calculations are also carried out. Comparison of the classical path and exact quantum results shows excellent agreement both in the specific inelastic cross section and in the individual partial-wave contributions.",
author = "James Muckerman and Millard Alexander and Isak Rusinek and Roberts, {R. E.}",
year = "1976",
language = "English",
volume = "65",
pages = "2416--2428",
journal = "Journal of Chemical Physics",
issn = "0021-9606",
publisher = "American Institute of Physics Publising LLC",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Probabilities for classically forbidden transitions using classical and classical path methods

AU - Muckerman, James

AU - Alexander, Millard

AU - Rusinek, Isak

AU - Roberts, R. E.

PY - 1976

Y1 - 1976

N2 - Limits are established for the applicability of purely classical methods for calculating nonreactive, inelastic transition probabilities in collinear collisions of a structureless atom and a harmonic oscillator. These limits, obtained by comparison with previous exact quantum mechanical results, indicate that such methods are inappropriate not only for "classically forbidden" but for many "classically allowed" transitions (in spite of the fact that they are widely used to calculate probabilities for such processes). A classical path method in the context of infinite-order time-dependent perturbation theory is described which yields extremely accurate transition probabilities even for the most classically forbidden transitions in the collinear atom-harmonic oscillator system. The essential features of this method are: (1) the use of the expectation value of the total interaction potential in determining the atom-oscillator (central force) trajectory, and (2) the use of the arithmetic mean of the initial and final velocities of relative motion in the (elastic) central force trajectory. This choice of interaction potential allows the relative motion to be coupled to changes in the internal state of the oscillator. The present classical method is further applied to three-dimensional atom-breathing sphere collisions, and exact quantum mechanical calculations are also carried out. Comparison of the classical path and exact quantum results shows excellent agreement both in the specific inelastic cross section and in the individual partial-wave contributions.

AB - Limits are established for the applicability of purely classical methods for calculating nonreactive, inelastic transition probabilities in collinear collisions of a structureless atom and a harmonic oscillator. These limits, obtained by comparison with previous exact quantum mechanical results, indicate that such methods are inappropriate not only for "classically forbidden" but for many "classically allowed" transitions (in spite of the fact that they are widely used to calculate probabilities for such processes). A classical path method in the context of infinite-order time-dependent perturbation theory is described which yields extremely accurate transition probabilities even for the most classically forbidden transitions in the collinear atom-harmonic oscillator system. The essential features of this method are: (1) the use of the expectation value of the total interaction potential in determining the atom-oscillator (central force) trajectory, and (2) the use of the arithmetic mean of the initial and final velocities of relative motion in the (elastic) central force trajectory. This choice of interaction potential allows the relative motion to be coupled to changes in the internal state of the oscillator. The present classical method is further applied to three-dimensional atom-breathing sphere collisions, and exact quantum mechanical calculations are also carried out. Comparison of the classical path and exact quantum results shows excellent agreement both in the specific inelastic cross section and in the individual partial-wave contributions.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0343887931&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0343887931&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0343887931

VL - 65

SP - 2416

EP - 2428

JO - Journal of Chemical Physics

JF - Journal of Chemical Physics

SN - 0021-9606

IS - 6

ER -